Jessica really likes VH1, and I won't argue to the contrary. I whizzed through my post-newscast production work last night to rush home and catch the network's
"Rock Honors", VH1's tribute to some heavy bands. I'm assuming that due to the complexity of the stages, pyro, rigging, amps and other idiosyncratic nuances of getting KISS, Judas Priest, Def Leppard and Queen to perform together that it was recorded over a several hours, if not days. The emphasis seemed to be on the performances, rather than having the honorees take the stage and say a few words, a la the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
But I dug it nonetheless...even watching half of the rebroadcast immediately after the first airing ended. Here's a linear segment-by-segment recap of what I thought of the performances:
- Penn Gillette, who I prefer more for his early 90's voiceover work at Comedy Central, opens the show with a 10-second - literally - crescendo into Foo Fighters covering Queen's "Tie Your Mother Down".
- Dave, Taylor and the other two guys in FF rocked out.
- Queen takes the stage. Oh, baby. I got goose bumps as Brian May soloed through "The Show Must Go On", which to this day is chilling, given it was one of Freddie Mercury's last recordings. I never realized what a strong frontman Paul Rodgers was/is. They also got the crowd into "We Will Rock You" and - of course - the obligatory b-side "We Are the Champions". Anything less would have been sacrilege. Blasphemy. A schism. Totally.
- A video history of Judas Priest follows a commercial break, in which Halford & Company talk about their humble Birmingham beginnings and being the first Metal Gods.
- Godsmack kills during as Priest tribute, ripping through a medley featuring "Hellion/The Electric Eye" and "Hell Bent for Leather". Sully's low-end drawl was a surprising nice contrast to Rob's signature shrieks.
- Priest takes the stage and leaves nothing in their wake. "Breaking the Law" and "You've Got Another Thing Comin'" made for a predictable playlist (I was hoping for "Painkiller"), but they tore it up nonetheless.
- I wasn't expecting too much out of All-American Rejects covering Leppard, but they did a very decent job on "Photograph"...and that was it. Nice take.
- Joe, Phil, Vivian, Rick, and Rick launched into "Rock of Ages" to the crowd's pleasure. I was disappointed when their second aired performance was a "...here's a number of ouur new CD...", covering a T-Rex song. That marked the only time I switched channels, briefly popping in on ESPN.
- ...and the wait is over. At last - KISS. The star-laden crew of Rob Zombie, Gilby Clarke, Tommy Lee, Slash and Scott Ian (who was hella cool on bass...Gene Simmons' trademark axe, no less) ripped through the timeless "God of Thunder", joined by Ace Frehley. That's an iTunes-purchaseworthy track right there, boy.
- KISS themselves launched into a mammoth production, playing to my surprise, "Detroit Rock City" and, my favorite song, "Love Gun". I loves me some "Rock and Roll All Night, Party Every Day", but the change was nice. I'm still hopeful for an online cut of "God Gave Rock n Roll to You". Geez - after all these years, Paul Stanley is still the man.
The only thing I thought was stupid was the air guitar competition. As a shredder myself, I've always found the practice to be vaguely amusing, but overall, too masturbatory for my tastes. Hell, if you spend that much time trying to emulate axe-wielding gods, learn how to play guitar.
The interactive component was cool...with only 2 performances aired, with a third exclusively webcast on
V-Spot, VH1's broadband channel. Really nice touch.
Overall, and speaking as a guy who's made a living out of creating great integreated TV/online programming, I give it a strong 'A'. Looking ahead to next year, I'm hoping for homage to be paid to Van Halen, Scorpions, Megadeth, and Black Sabbath. Good job, VH1!