Tuesday, December 30, 2008
BlackBerry Storm: nice try, RIM
Since yesterday I've been messing with the BlackBerry Storm after a local wireless provider dropped off a handset for my station to evaluate for our tech segment. The reviews on it are mainly unfavorable, but with disbelief suspended I wanted to draw my own objective conclusions. And they're not good.
(Note: this is my own personal review, not that of my company.)
RIM's newest smartphone is an obvious overdue reaction to the global iPhone craze; Verizon's trying to recoup some of the chutzpah it lost to AT&T and T-Mobile. They just simply showed up too late to this Kool-Aid party...and they brought Juicy Juice.
I have an appreciation for the form factor a revolutionary device like Apple's iPhone/iTunes/AppStore telephony ecosystem brings to the table, and Google's Android mobile OS on the G1 has done a good job at emulating the touchscreen interface, auto-rotating screen orientation, use of an accelerometer for motion detection, and slick GPS functionality for location-aware features. The Storm tries, too, but falls short. It's just not the same.
That said, I'm a big fan of the software/hardware changes RIM made with the BlackBerry Bold. That line can hold its own among its contemporaries (which notably doesn't include the iPhone or G1). For me the Storm, being a guy who's extensively used the iPhone/iPod Touch UI, is an inferior disappointment. While there's still no app store for the BlackBerry and that development platform essentially remaining a closed platform, it's hard to win me over. And the IM and push e-mail that have been BlackBerry's bread-and-butter aren't that valuable to merit an upgrade investment as high as $700 for a device that pales by comparison to its touchscreen cousins.
I constantly find myself thinking "this isn't as good an experience as I would have on an iPhone" and I just can't break away from that.
But don't take my word for it - check it out for yourself. I'm not abandoning RIM, I'm good with my Bold. But for me, this Storm's far from perfect.
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]
Post a Comment